Followers of the Tyneside club are progressively viewing Eddie Howe's side as an unreliable ally. When everything clicks, they can be the very entertainers, delivering breathtaking exhibitions. However, on other occasions, previously reliable figures like Sandro Tonali and his teammates utterly go missing.
Compounding the frustration is a late-game approach riddled with a worrying tendency of panic. Ahead of their Boxing Day to Manchester United, the numbers reveal a sobering story: the team has let slip 13 crucial top-flight points from winning situations this campaign and are yet to keep a shutout in ten consecutive games across all competitions. Earning a win at their famous stadium would constitute only their second league triumph on the travel this season.
In contrast, defeat has only come on one occasion in their last 6 league encounters, and although occupying a seemingly lowly 11th position, they are a only 6 marks behind the highly-prized Champions League places. Add in an impending two-legged League Cup semi-final against the reigning champions and a strong opportunity of progressing to the Champions League knockout phase, and it is simpler to see the manager's guarded optimism.
“Our issues aren't limited to difficulties,” remarked the club's head coach. “You can see positives also. I am decidedly optimistic right now. I understand others may hold a opposing opinion, but my belief is we are getting better.”
The question is: will this squad recapture – or even exceed – the successes of last season's cup glory and European-qualifying finish? Managing a packed schedule hinders.
The resulting heavy-leggedness could account for the failure to maintain a brilliant first-half performance against their London rivals, eventually squandering a 2-0 advantage to draw 2-2. Likewise, it is possibly the reason for a subdued performance in a painful defeat to arch-rivals Sunderland, where the team seemed sluggish just days after a demanding European away day.
While on-field instruction is clearly the manager's specialty, the constant grind of two games a week football has drastically cut into crucial practice sessions. This slows the team's tactical adjustment to playing with summer signing Nick Woltemade up front, rather than the now departed Alexander Isak. Although extremely talented, the German forward does not possess the same electric counter-attacking speed or ferocious defensive work rate.
In fact, the team's signature high press has sporadically malfunctioned. Injuries to key engine Joelinton have been a factor, while high-profile arrivals Anthony Elanga and Jacob Ramsey have struggled settling since their substantial transfers.
If a switch to a three-man defense could theoretically benefit the team, a full-blown defensive injury list makes that difficult. Key defenders will be absent for the upcoming crucial fixtures, challenging the team's resilience.
At their ferocious best, they look virtually unstoppable. The problem is maintaining that fervor for the entire 90 minutes. The go-to plan B of dropping deep into a passive defensive formation has at times been counterproductive.
“The Chelsea game descended into chaotic at 2-2,” conceded the coach. “But we were going for the victory. Our mentality is to always try to secure the three points.”
What appears called for is a middle ground – involving better ball retention, a engine room adept of controlling the pace, and a pragmatic willingness to sometimes accept a point. Yet, a determination to compete on every competitions is stretching finite squad numbers to their limit.
This might sound unthinkable to some, but a different strategy in the domestic cups earlier could have eased the current fixture pile-up. Amid vital European and Premier League games on the agenda, the need to carefully prioritize is growing ever more apparent.
Eddie Howe recognized the size of the task remaining. “When you're involved this club, the demands are big. Each game is critical. There is progress to be made in the league. We are in the Carabao Cup last four, we aim to progress in the Europe and perform in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the correct path, but we have lots of work to do to transform into the regularly successful team we aspire to be. Our capacity to put sequences of victories has eluded us this season.
“The objective is to hit that standard we know we're capable of. My feeling is that the assurance we can achieve it is growing. Yet nowadays we have to show it. It ain't all bad right now, but the next few weeks will determine a great deal.”
A tech journalist and AI researcher with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and their impact on society.